Appellate Counsel For California Trial Lawyers
home_billboard

How to Read an Insurance Policy

Insurance policies must be drafted in clear language

The law requires that insurance policies be drafted in clear language. But anyone who has tried to read an insurance policy knows that they are seldom clear and that they are almost always difficult to read and understand.

Determining what the policy covers and does not cover can be made a little bit easier by knowing how insurance policies are typically structured. Almost all policies are structured in the following way:

Insurance policy declarations

The “declarations” page is usually the first page of the policy. It is often typed instead of being on a pre-printed form. It will show who the “named insured” of the policy is, and will list the type of coverages that are provided in the policy (such as “dwelling” or “property damage” or “liability.”) The declarations also list coverage limits for each type of coverage (in other words, the amount of coverage that has been purchased), and will list the endorsements that are part of the policy.

Definitions

The “definitions” explain how the insurance company has used certain words or terms in the policy. For example, the policy is likely to refer to the insurance company as “us.” The term “us” will be a defined term in the policy. Similarly, the policy will refer to “you” and that term will be defined to mean “the named insured referred to in the declarations.”

Coverages

The “coverages” contain the promises that the insurance company has made. They explain what the policy provides coverage for.

Exclusions

“Exclusions” are provisions that take away coverage that would otherwise be provided by the policy. For example, a health-insurance policy might promise to pay for all medically-necessary treatment required by the policyholder, but this broad promise will be qualified by an exclusion for treatment that is deemed “experimental.”

Conditions

The “conditions” explain what the policyholder must do in order to qualify for coverage in the event of a loss, and explain how losses will be paid. For example, in a homeowner’s policy, a typical condition of coverage is that the loss be reported to the insurer within a year after it occurs. Some conditions in the policy will be strictly enforced. Others, by contrast, will be subject to statutes or legal rules that effectively make them unenforceable.

Endorsements

“Endorsements” are special provisions added to the policy to change its terms. They are most commonly used to modify the terms of a policy after it has been issued. Rather than issue an entirely new policy, the insurer will simply issue an endorsement that refers to the part of the policy it is changing, and which will replace that provision.
Sometimes, insurance companies will issue a basic policy, but will allow the policyholder to purchase additional types of coverage by paying an increased premium.

These special coverages will often be added by endorsement. For example, a homeowner’s policy will typically exclude all coverage for earth movement, and hence does not cover losses caused by an earthquake. But for an extra premium, the carrier may add earthquake coverage, and this coverage will be provided by an endorsement.

Making sense of it all (or not)

It can sometimes be difficult to differentiate between the parts of a policy. Insurers may limit coverage by defining policy terms in a special way. Or they may include language in one section of the policy that would seem to belong in a different section. For example, they may limit the scope of a coverage with exclusionary language contained within the insuring clause, instead of in a separate exclusion. Or they may limit the scope of an exclusion by inserting language that creates an exception to its operation. (This is called an exception to an exclusion.)

As a result, it is often difficult for anyone other than an expert to be able to read an insurance policy and know what it covers, and sometimes even the experts will disagree.


California insurance appeals attorney, Jeffrey I. Ehrlich, is an appellate specialist certified by the State Bar of California’s Committee on Legal Specialization. He is a principal of the Ehrlich Law Firm, and handles legal appeals throughout California.

Categories: Articles & Briefs

Appellate Passion: Jeffrey Ehrlich has helped set precedent, but he’s proudest of getting one man out of prison.
Los Angeles & San Francisco Daily Journal,
Monday, May 21, 2018

Read more about the Ray Jennings Case

Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

News

Success on appeal in California depends on many things — the facts that underlie your case, the legal positions you can take in light of the state of the law, your skill in selecting and presenting the issues to the appellate court in a persuasive… Read More
Getting a case from the pleading stage through trial can be like trying to walk through a minefield. There are always procedural traps lurking to snare the unwary trial lawyer. Here are 10 easy, and distressingly common mistakes for a trial lawyer to… Read More
In most cases, the providers decide what is covered and what is not covered, without any input from the HMO. (Although in most cases, the member can appeal the decision to the HMO.) The HMO is, in essence, nothing more than a middleman. So, can you s… Read More

View All News