Ehrlich Law Firm wins insurance bad-faith victory in California Supreme Court
Phone: (818) 905-3970
Email: The Ehrlich Firm
Insurance companies in California can no longer prevail in bad-faith lawsuits brought by their policyholders simply by showing that there was a "dispute" about whether the insurer should pay the claim. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the Supreme Court reined in the so-called "genuine dispute rule" that had become the insurance industries' most potent defense in bad-faith cases, holding that the rule only applied at the summary-judgment stage, and then only in cases where a jury would be unable to make a finding that the insurer had acted unreasonably. The Wilson ruling makes it much harder for insurers to obtain summary judgment in bad-faith lawsuit.
Download Wilson v. 21st Century Insurance Decision (.pdf)
More News
Published Articles | Jeffrey I. Ehrlich, Appellate Specialist
The basics of California Appeals — two not-so-simple rules: Filing a timely notice of appeal and designating a proper record
10 Common mistakes that trial lawyers make and how to avoid them
The ever-expanding genuine-dispute doctrine, and how to deal with it. Advocate. August 2007 | Download .pdf
The genuine dispute doctrine after Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co.
Advocate. August 2008 | Download .pdf
Defeating the "Genuine Issue" Defense at Summary Judgment. By William M. Shernoff and Jeffrey I. Ehrlich.| Download .pdf
How to preserve it for appeal: The right way to to make a record. Adocate. February 2008 | Download .pdf
An interview with Justice Paul Turner. Advocate. December 2007 | Download .pdf
When Arbitration Becomes Impossible: When are parties excused from an agreement to arbitrate? Advocate. January 2006. | Download .pdf
Starting a solo practice: One lawyer's odessy. Advocate. July 2007 | Download .pdf
Six tips for effective writ practice. Advocate. January 2006 | Download .pdf
Be prepared for the new statuatory changes that will affect the filing of writ petitions in California. Advocate. 2002 | Download .pdf
It's looking a lot like 1989: Changes in the law governing the construction of insurance policies in California. Consumers Attorneys of California (CAOC). June 2004.| Download .pdf
Can HMOs avoid liability for withholding care and shortening the life of a terminally ill plan member? Consumers Attorneys of California (CAOC). January/February 2002. | Download .pdf
Stumbling out of the starting gate: the first decision to apply State Farm v. Campbell gets it wrong. Daily Journal. September 5, 2003. | Download .pdf
Effective Oppositions to Motions for Summary Judgment | Download .pdf
Pegram v. Herdrich, 90 days later. | Download .pdf
Ruling Clarifies Federal ERISA Pre-Emption of State Measures: Kentucky Association of Health Plans, Inc. v. Miller, 123 S.Ct. 1471(2003). | Download .pdf